Can we please stop ‘translating’ Japanese

pensive ethnic man listening to answer in paper cup phone

Those who have any experience dealing with bringing Japanese words into English should be able to relate. We all know that Japanese and English are linguistically very far apart, and that there are many times when things simply don’t have an English equivalent. That’s a story for another time.

I’m talking about the amazing ability Japanese people have to create extremely long-winded sentences that people seem to have no complaints about, the sorts of sentences that combine multiple clauses into one mega sentence that if translated into English could easily be three or even more sentences, you know the ones I mean, right?

I’m also talking about uniquely Japanese concepts that Japanese people assume non-Japanese people know.

Edo period, anyone?

Simply translating things is not enough. Not only is it tough to read, at times it also requires an encyclopedia. When we think about the aims of translating in the first place, of giving speakers of other languages the ability to understand things from an entirely different culture, then it should be obvious translation alone is insufficient.

What we need is someone with an innate knowledge of at least one of the cultures, as well as domain knowledge, coupled with the pure ability to write. Achieve this, and we’re on the right path to building greater intercultural understanding.

Which is what we’re after, no?

As a translator, this is your permission to add extra knowledge you deem necessary. It’s also your permission to. Cut. Sentences. Up. If they run too long.

ENJOYED THIS? HAVE MORE.

MOUNTAINS OF WISDOM

Subscribe to my yamabushi newsletter

RECENT BLOG POSTS

Tim Bunting AKA Kiwi Yamabushi on Zao-san
However slow you go
Tim Bunting AKA Kiwi Yamabushi on Zao-san
Make it. Do it.
Tim Bunting AKA Kiwi Yamabushi on Zao-san
Don’t even think about it

YAMABUSHI BLOG POSTS

a statue of a man near the clouds
Aiming for Perfection?
Mt. Chokai above the sea of Japan
How Yamabushi get through the tough parts
Flower in Japan in autumn shot by Tim Bunting
Taking the chance to understand

RANDOM POSTS

selective focus photography of traffic light
Light up my way
What you wanna get
One Year Climbing the Mountains of Yamagata
Tim Bunting Kiwi Yamabushi

Tim Bunting Kiwi Yamabushi

Get In Touch

Sakata City, Yamagata, Japan 

tim@timbunting.com

Share this:

Like this:

Like Loading...
Scroll to Top